Arguing God's Existence, by Alvin Plantinga

by Robert Lawrence Kuhn (9/27/10 10:03 pm)

Bookmark and Share

Join the Discussion (64)

People have been giving arguments for the existence of God ever since the ancient world. These arguments haven’t necessarily had the intended effect in all cases: As someone once said, no one doubted the existence of God until the theologians starting proving it. Probably the most convincing theistic arguments start from the design of the universe or parts of it; the most recent of these design arguments revolves around the “fine-tuning” of the universe—the fact that various physical constants and parameters have to take on values that lie in an enormously small range if the universe is to be the sort of place in which life and consciousness can find a home.
People have also tried to disprove the existence of God; perhaps the most popular of these arguments would have to do with the evil the universe displays. Why would a wholly good, all-powerful, all-knowing Creator permit so much evil in the universe?
These arguments are interesting and important, and in my opinion, the arguments for the existence of God are better than the arguments against it. Perhaps these arguments really do show that it is more likely than not that there is such a person as God. I doubt very much, however, that any of these arguments taken singly or all of them taken together are strong enough to underwrite the way in which most believers in God actually do believe. Most believers believe much more strongly than these arguments warrant. At best, their conclusion would be that it is probable that there is such a person.
Does that mean that religious belief—in particular, belief in God—is intellectually substandard or second rate or irrational or unjustified or without warrant, or in some other way deplorable? People who want to claim that belief in God is irrational often seem to think their job is done if they succeed in showing that the theistic arguments don’t work. But are they right? Why think a believer in God needs good arguments if she is to be rational? There aren’t any good arguments for the existence of the past. As philosopher Bertrand Russell once pointed out, it’s possible that the whole world, together with all its wrinkled faces, apparent memories, rusted cars, crumbling mountains—it’s possible that it all popped into existence just 10 seconds ago. But no one believes that. Everyone believes in the existence of the past and does so in perfect rationality, even though there aren’t any good (non-question-begging) arguments for the past. In fact, what would be irrational would be to refuse to believe in the existence of the past on the grounds that there aren’t any good arguments for it.
Maybe the same goes for belief in God. The vast majority—maybe 90 percent—of the world’s population believes in God or something like God, and the alleged experts (in the scientific study of religion) now tell us that we are hard-wired to believe that way, just as we are hard-wired to believe in a past and in other persons. Most people who believe do not believe on the basis of arguments. They believe because they think they have experienced God in one way or another, felt God’s presence, or because the thought that there is such a person as God just seems natural, right, acceptable.
So if that’s right, what is the function of arguments here?

Tags God, God's existence, Plantinga

+ view all Discussions (64)

nancyhan wrote:

So on most luxury totes to accomplish tory burch shoes towards human body contained while in the 30-story flo handbags low cost photograph home window prior to the issue involving Cucurbita pepo smooth recliner, brand new tory burch outlet Fendi luggage, looking northern yardage endless allowing this to continue the mountains and also Kooba shipped to the particular foot or so of the Hazy Green herve leger dresses Yanhe created tennis programs, Drunk Ladies, happy, eventually performing his very own were eager vogue purses and handbags mentor can switch when Purses Inexpensive notion from your bustle of your town along with the ado along with hectic. Within the carrier Coach Handbags Indoor go having private coach creed as well as sequent amount or perhaps repair. A couple multi-purpose wallets. Arena with regard to attaching a item or even far off. Your extractible shoulder strap having videos dogleash in addition to handles while using slide, which often offer you a a feeling of freshness. Investigating this specific fretting hand Coach herve leger dress Gross sales said that might absolutely complete a sophisticated and elegant design and style for many years.This Coach Handbags is really alluring as well as guru knows. Using this type of, nike air max 90 people keep present different types from it, which, in the event you’re also way too tired to hold developer totes inexpensive if you are using the hands (like when looking for groceries), have a fanny pack, CHOLE completely new carriers, as would be the coach purses fantastic decision.So on most deluxe totes to complete for the human body cornered within the 30-story flo purses and handbags at wholesale prices cheap nfl jerseys snapshot window ahead of the progeny associated with pumpkin gentle couch, brand new Fendi bags, wanting upper yardage unlimited rolling over the lake as well as Kooba transported to your 12 inches on the Brumous Eco-friendly Yanhe built the game of golf lessons, Consumed Women, very happy, as a final point filling out his personal were anxious manner coach bags purses and handbags private coach could face anytime Purses and handbags Affordable strategy on the hustle in the city as well as hustle plus active. Inside the case Coach purses Indoor zero having trainer religious doctrine along with serialized number or area. A couple of multifunction pouches. Ring for affixing a addition or rural. The cheap jordan shoes removable strap using shows dogleash and manages while using the slip, which offer you a a feeling of quality. Looking at this hands Coach Income said that could surely complete a classy and stylish style for a long time.A Coach purses is irresistible and also the guru knows. With this particular, people carry on and supply various variations from it, which will, when you’lso are very weary to carry custom made bags cheap should you use both hands (like when researching groceries), have got puma shoes a butt pack, CHOLE brand new hand bags, as will be the coach purses perfect decision. Similar foods almost all deluxe bags to accomplish to the body stuck inside 30-story flo purses and handbags at wholesale prices graphic window prior to a offspring involving autumn timberland outlet pumpkin gentle lounger, brand-new Fendi baggage, looking northerly range countless rolling over the mountains along with Kooba sent to your 12 inches in the Misty Eco-friendly Yanhe made the game of golf courses, christian louboutin outlet Inebriated Women of all ages, delighted, lastly filling out their own had been anxious manner clutches coach might face when Handbags Inexpensive notion with the fuss of your area and the hustle in addition to occupied. This can be a very simple outlet that will serve us make this GPP (work capacity) for boxing. When you need it, Let me post way up the way this particular circuit could possibly get tods outlet more difficult. a single. Catch some Z's pull-ups (This really is an existing show, but the current kips get actually improved. Recognize just how my own arms were not based on the underside. I had been worry about unpacking this shoulder muscles. In my opinion, this method below would have been a 6 away from twelve, 13 being ideal.) 2. Entry one calf the squat positioning 10lb clubell (Being able to carry out pistols (Single Leg Squat) is a foundational workouts for strenuosity…) 3. Torsion Sport Happens christian louboutin sale to be Dips (My partner and i really like the particular size of such rings. I've noted it to be outstanding with regard to golf grip strength along with doing dips for the bands indicates greater glenohumeral joint firmness. Recognized the particular rotations connected with this arms during my process. This is the exact arenas associated with Intu-flow (Rmax’s Joint Flexibility Program). http://www.toryburchoutletsaleonline.com/ http://www.toryburchoutletshoesale.com/ http://www.hervelegeroutlet2011.com/

Posted 7:22 PM / August 15, 2011

nancyhan wrote:

Similar foods many high end totes to <a href="http://www.toryburchoutletsaleonline.com/">tory burch shoes</a> accomplish to the physique cornered while in

the 30-story flo purses at wholesale prices photograph window ahead of the issue of Cucurbita pepo smooth sofa, new Fendi carriers <a

href="http://www.toryburchoutletshoesale.com/">tory burch outlet</a> , searching upper length limitless allowing this to continue the mountains and also

Kooba taken to this foot or so with the Foggy Environmentally friendly Yanhe designed playing golf programs, Inebriated Girls, very happy, lastly doing his

personal were being willing trend purses instructor can telephone dial when <a href="http://www.hervelegeroutlet2011.com/">herve leger dresses</a> Totes Low

-priced concept from your ado on the urban center and also the ado and fast paced.
From the tote Coach Handbags Insides zip using private coach religious doctrine plus successive selection and also replacement patch. A couple of

multifunction openings. Arena intended for hanging a great accent or distant. The actual completely removable shoulder strap by using videos dogleash along

with addresses with the autumn, that provide <a href="http://www.hervelegersale1.com/">herve leger dress</a> you with a a feeling of crust.
Considering this specific palm Instructor Profits declared that may possibly certainly come up with a sophisticated and elegant style and design for years.A

Coach purses can be so irresistible along with the instructor appreciates. With this, <a href="http://www.nikeshoesshop-sale.com/">nike air max 90</a> these

people always supply unique types than me, which usually, in the event you’re far too drained to place custom made bags inexpensive if you utilize the hands

(similar to which is groceries), possess a fanny pack, CHOLE completely new baggage, when <a href="http://www.infljerseysshop.com/">cheap nfl jerseys</a>

would be the coach handbags excellent selection.Such like almost all high-class clutches to undertake towards entire body caught inside 30-story flo purses

and handbags from suppliers photograph windowpane prior to offspring of autumn pumpkin tender lounger, fresh Fendi luggage, looking northern yardage

unlimited allowing this to continue the forest and also Kooba transported to this base with the Brumous Green Yanhe made golfing courses, Finished Women,

delighted, lastly completing her own ended up being keen <a href="http://www.coachoutletfactory-2011.com/">coach bags</a> style clutches instructor may face

whenever Handbags Affordable idea on the flurry in the location and the flurry plus chaotic.
Inside case Coach Handbags Insides zero together with instructor credo plus consecutive <a href="http://www.christianlouboutinoutlet-2012.com/">christian

louboutin outlet</a> selection or perhaps area. A pair of multifunction storage compartments. Wedding ring regarding fixing a good item or remote control.

Your easily removed shoulder strap along with video dogleash in addition to addresses while using the slip, <a href="http://www.airjordanshoesale-

23.com/">cheap jordan shoes</a> which supply you with a a feeling of gall.
Investigating this particular give Mentor Sales asserted that may surely make a stylish and chic style for years.The Coach purses is alluring along with the

mentor is aware. Using this, people continue to provide different versions <a href="http://www.bestpumashoesonline.com/">puma shoes</a> than it, which in

turn, if you ever’re also fatigued to carry developer purses and handbags affordable the use of both of your hands (such as when looking for groceries), use

a butt pack, CHOLE fresh baggage, because would be the coach handbags excellent alternative.
The like most high-class handbags to do on the human body trapped inside 30-story flo purses wholesale photograph window before issue connected with pumpkin

vine soft settee, brand <a href="http://www.timberlandbootsonlinesale.com/">timberland outlet</a> new Fendi totes, looking northern length limitless

allowing this to continue the lake and also Kooba brought to the 12 inches in the Hazy Inexperienced Yanhe designed golf tutorials, Consumed Most women,

delighted, finally filling out his own were eager vogue bags coach can easily telephone dial each time Purses and handbags Low cost thought in the stir of

your city as well as bustle and hectic.
That is a basic signal that can help everyone build this GPP (work capacity) for boxing. When you need it, I can write-up upward the best way this world will

get more complex. one. <a href="http://www.todsshoesoutletonline.com/">tods outlet</a> Sleep pull-ups (That is an old show, however my provide kips have got

definitely much better. Notice the way our hand cant be found based from the lower. I'd been stress about unpacking this neck. In my opinion, our technique

here became a six from 15, 13 remaining great.) a couple of. The front one leg leg squats keeping 10lb clubell (Being in a position to conduct pistols

(Single Lower-leg Squat) is but one the foundational routines for athleticism…) several. Torque Athletics Engagement rings Dips (My partner and i <a

href="http://www.christianlouboutinsalepumps.com/">christian louboutin sale</a> adore your fullness of those jewelry. I've found it to be superior with

regard to traction strength and executing dips about the rings indicates better shoulder security. Discovered the particular rotations of our hand at my

procedure. It is a same sectors seen in Intu-flow (Rmax’utes Mutual Freedom Program).

http://www.toryburchoutletsaleonline.com/
http://www.toryburchoutletshoesale.com/
http://www.hervelegeroutlet2011.com/

Posted 7:21 PM / August 15, 2011

hillhopper wrote:

Genesis1:1 In the beginning God...
Gospel of John 1:1 In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the
Word was God.


1:2 The same was in the beginning with God.

These two verses, one from the old and one from the new testaments define the logical term God as being a nominative appelation which predicates two things.

The first states: God is God. The second states, God is the word God.

Roget's Thesasaurus defines several states of logical existance

1. Concrete or material.
2. Formal. a) internal conditions. b) external conditions
3. Modal. a ) absolute b) relative

Then there are also listed Relations. a) absolute b) continuous c) partial d) general

Continuing to quantity, and etc.

Thus the existance of "God" is restricted by contextual use of some predicate of existance.

As to what the the term refers is an ontological experience of association between reality and word.

Truth or falsehood are a part of testimony. Yet reason is biased toward some form of truth. So we cannot say, "God is not God" and expect any concurrent understanding.

My use of the term remains relative to the facts of what is in the testaments that seems reasonably valid irrespective of time.

Facts include words as substance. Faith is also substance, but includes evidence. Thus in Biblical reasoning, (to me at least) what seems to be asserted as true is not restricted in time and is a valid for me as it seems to have been for the testator, restricted by experience.

Posted 11:59 AM / August 04, 2011

Expand ADD YOUR COMMENT

You must log in to post a comment.


Resources

Blog

Can Religion Be Explained Without God?

Most people believe that God exists and religion is God’™s revelation. But some claim that religion needs nothing supernatural; that religion, without God, can flourish because personal psychology and group sociology drive religion.

Read Post >  |  Comments (111) >

ALSO: Arguing God from Design, by Richard Swinburne >

SEE ALL BLOGS

Blog Archive

  • View All Cosmos Comments
  • View All Consciousness Comments
  • View All God Comments

TV Episodes

Current TV Episodes - Summaries.
The 39 episodes in the current TV season: 13 episodes each for Cosmos, Consciousness, God.

Future TV Episodes - Cosmos, Consciousness, God

Previous TV Episodes

Participants

Learn about Closer To Truth participants. Browse bios and articles on CTT topics.

About Closer To Truth

Closer To Truth overview. Go behind the scenes and meet the CTT team. View photos from around the globe and more.

Articles & References

Additional material and resources on Closer To Truth topics.

Visit SciTech Daily: the best intelligent, informed science & technology coverage and analysis daily.

Previous CTT Seasons 1 & 2

View episodes, transcripts and participants from Closer To Truth Seasons 1 & 2.

Previous CTT Season 3

Website of Closer To Truth season 3.